Movie Review: "The Martian" Has Scientific Flaws

“Discovery News” and NASA want you to understand that the upcoming movie, “The Martian,” has some scientific errors made for the sake of drama, that is, making the movie watchable.

“Although dust storms on Mars come with their hazards, it’s highly unlikely that any storm would be powerful enough to strand astronauts on the surface or rip apart equipment.”

“The Martian Winds WON’T Blow You Away”
http://news.discovery.com/space/the-martian-winds-wont-blow-you-away-150921.htm

You see, folks, atmospheric pressure at the Martian surface is what we would call a vacuum (or, more accurately, a partial vacuum) on Earth. The winds of Mars have just enough force to move talcum-like dust particles. Even at sixty miles per hour, Martian winds would exert about as much force as a five mile per hour breeze on Earth. So, even the fiercest gale on Mars isn’t likely to move much mass.

Even if Mars could generate the winds portrayed in the movie, such winds would make launching a rocket successfully all-but impossible. More likely, astronauts caught in such a storm–a storm likely is impossible on Mars–would have to stay on the surface.

2 Likes

A little thing called “suspension of disbelief” goes a long way towards enjoying movies.

Wait! You’re telling me Hollywood can’t be trusted to give actual FACTS! I’m crushed! Next you will be telling me Darth Vader never existed! Just kidding! I did not know that the Martian atmosphere was that sparse! Thanks for that info. I will need to brush up on my planetary knowledge. Geez… I might have talked to my Martian abductors and seemed like a complete idiot to them! Seriously though, I wish Hollywood would do some homework. Still I had heard that Andy Weir, the book’s author, had done significant research. Oh well, all our heroes have their Kryptonite!

Just watch out for wormsign when you are on Mars. The shai-hulud can be nasty buggers. :slight_smile:

1 Like